Showing posts with label advertising. Show all posts
Showing posts with label advertising. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Exclamation Point Marketing!!!!!??

Is it just me or has the marketing profession has lost something in the past few years? Lately it seems to me that hype, promotion and volume have replaced cleverness, innovation and values.

Maybe it was too much Billy Mays yelling at me & now Sully, his smarmy Pitchmen buddy; maybe it is the current US obsession with tabloid journalism and personal desire for celebrity; possibly another casualty of the Wal-Mart effect. I could blame the Internet, video gaming, mobile content, maybe even El Nino. Safe to say, I haven’t determined the root cause, but I do know that brand marketing has lost a bit of luster recently.

Being a brand sensitive individual and one who was raised in the industry to develop, nurture and evangelize the value and critical importance of brands, I must say sometimes I feel a bit lost. We see brand extension after brand extension. Companies that have built great brands and good businesses like Di Giorno sold off for logistics reasons, not marketing issues.

Where, oh where is the customer in all this? It often appears that we have lost sight of their needs, desires and hopes. Or are we just determined to sell them stuff; at low prices? in massive quantities? Maybe that’s what they want and I don’t know it.

I, like so many, look forward to the Super Bowl coming, as much for the half-time entertainment, football and the commercials. This annual seminal moment in TV advertising is analyzed nearly as much as the X’s and O’s. Who is in, who’s out, how much are they spending.

What amazes me about Super Bowl ads (and now advertising in general) is how little the ads even talk about the product, if at all. I wonder if Danica Patrick even knows or cares about what Go Daddy does? More importantly, how many viewers even care. No doubt many young men find out they are a domain listing service, very few who have their own website.

One might excuse Go Daddy, but when such respected marketers as Budweiser airing ads that are never linked to the product, in any way, it hurts. If advertising is merely an attempt to entertain the audience, how effective can it be in shaping image or building awareness, trial and preference? Is it that marketers are just being lazy? Or going for the low hanging fruit? Or are consumers not demanding enough of the brands they upon which they spend?

My experience from 15 years of advertising tells me that some of the brightest and ambitious people - smart, clever, curious, insightful and driven- work in the field of advertising. They cannot be proud of some of the work out there. Advertising can be entertaining AND smart, strategic and on message. The current E*Trade campaign is spot on; funny, resonates with audiences; campaignable and flexible across media, including viral.

It can be done, but it takes a client that demands GREAT work and won’t settle for less!!!

Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Moving Towards a True Integrated Marketing Philosophy

Raise the topic of integrated marketing among marketer and watch heads nod briskly. It is not so clear if it is in acknowledgment of the fundamental soundness and pragmatic value or in application. It seems that few brands and companies really understand and embrace the practice.

Why is this? Surely we have moved past the naive understanding that ‘integrated’ meant all creative executions looked similar and were delivered to the market around the same time. Despite the rational support for implementing integrated marketing, there are some institutional boundaries that restrict it.

I suspect that many CMOs grew up in business with TV as the pinnacle of brand marketing activities; just now are we seeing senior marketers who have been “digital” for most of their life. These factors are not easy to overcome, but will as the next generation of CMOs emerges. In addition, the advertising world still portrays the big general agency who does TV and Print with greater reverence and esteem. These factors, plus agency compensation models have made true integrated marketing difficult.

So what is wrong with this approach, you ask? Let’s examine a typical approach for a brand campaign.

1. The general agency (as the lead agency) participates in developing or tweaking the Brand Positioning, from which the Big Idea is established.
2. The general agency develops TV Story Boards and Executions, with CMO and Senior Marketing staff involvement.
3. Other media leads (digital, direct marketing, PR, shopper, sponsorship, etc.) are then tasked with adapting the TV idea; too often via awkward agency to agency briefings.
4. Media planners is left to stitch together a cohesive plan by sequencing buys.

Rather than the waterfall cascade from TV to other communication, would it not be a better use of resources to have all agencies and marketers participate in the brand positioning and big idea development? With today’s multi-touch media and multi-channel distribution model, it is necessary to include broader viewpoints than just that of the TV audience. This will also enable media centered ideas to emerge upfront; critical with the plethora of social web choices available.

By engaging broader agency and brand resources to participate in evolving the campaign ideas, a richer and more vibrant discussion will ensue. The potential of having smart creative people build upon each other and create synergistic and linked programs is significant. No one agency or media form has a lock on good thinking, if we are open the possibilities. And, given the new media horizon the traditional approach has to be scrapped, since niche to mass is becoming a more common pattern.

No doubt, this will require advertisers and brands to take a very clear and firm stance with their agencies that all planning will be done in a collaborative and integrated manner. (Not to mention the ego soothing and hand holding needed). But the biggest challenge may lie with agency structures and compensation.

An ideal scenario might be one where a brand works with an agency holding company and defines the types of resources desired. It is up to that holding company to provide a ‘virtual team’ of the best and proper people at any given time to meet the needs. This could involve a mish-mash of people from general, media planning, digital etc. across their organization. Many boutique agencies follow this pattern now – working with strategic partners to supply critical resources a project requires, but not charging the client when not needed.

I expect the agency issue is not easy to resolve, but when enough client’s demand that approach it will be. The most critical opportunity is for clients to make the move to true integrated marketing for it is a better approach in meeting customer needs and maximizing the relationship and ultimately shareholder value

Monday, April 6, 2009

Share of Voice – A Key Metric That Has Lost Its Place?

In the mid ‘90s I worked in competitive analysis for a market leader consumer services brand during an extremely active and aggressive period in the market. The business was led by a hyper kinetic guy who left no challenge unanswered and was always angling for a squabble. It was a great learning experience that reinforced the need for sound business and marketing strategy.

I was tracking the advertising and Mar-com for four major competitors. We were tasked with understanding the message, promotions, offers and target audiences. We also looked extensively at the media types, investment and share of voice, going to great expense to have a pretty accurate handle on the numbers.

Interestingly, the senior executives never warmed up to or really “GOT” the importance of the Share of Voice (SOV) or Share of Spending (SOS). They were most intrigued by the creative, give-aways and offers. Our team put together a terrific presentation on the correlation of Share of Voice to Share of Market (SOM); using a classic marketing science book entitled The Wheel of Marketing by James Peckham Sr.

Peckham had analyzed several hundred leading package goods brands from 1946 to 1975 while working for Nielsen Data Corp.

The key conclusions were:

• SOV/SOM is key; if not the best indicator of what level of media support is needed to drive share growth.
• 96% of leading brands that grew share maintained SOV/SOM ratios exceeding 100%
• There is a substantial lag effect resulting from SOV/SOM ratio changes and actual market share impacts.
• SOV/SOM must be sustained for a long period to drive share changes.
• The greater uniformity/equality that exists among the competition on the quality of advertising and brand benefits, the stronger the correlation of SOV/SOM.
• Brands with news or high growth categories get a better return on increased SOV/SOM ratio.
• The following circumstances require greater SOV/SOM ratio to grow share:
- New brands generally need a disproportionate ratio (150 to 200 indexes) to get a foothold and grow.
- Longer purchase cycles.
- New brands without a quality or equity difference.
• The theory of SOV/SOM ratio does not hold for the following situations:
- A major price change by one brand
- A brand pre-launch or significant new innovation
- Entry of a significant, dynamic brand
- Much more compelling message, copy or creative for one brand
- Dramatically poorer brand image or equity


The extensive data that backed these analyses won over the marketing staff to a more scientifically driven approach to the media plan and market analysis. To be clear, it was not easy or inexpensive to compile the data, especially in a highly active market. It was also challenging to apply CPG models to a services industry. Yet, it was very worth it as it moved the ‘non-marketing types’ who held important marketing roles away from their obsession on creative issues and allowed the professionals to run advertising and mar-com.

These days, with many more media forms and the fracturing of the marketplace and audiences, SOM calculation is even more challenging. However, for any brand that can isolate a target segment and media, this analysis can be very beneficial.

A couple of important learnings for me were that data and facts will always sway the discussion and that marketing is part science, along with an art form